Expert Reaction

EXPERT REACTION: Mission to map Australia’s undiscovered biodiversity predicted to bring big economic benefits

Publicly released:
Australia; NSW; VIC; QLD; SA; WA; ACT
Taxonomy Australia
Taxonomy Australia

A new report by Deloitte Access Economics has found every $1 invested in discovering all remaining Australian species will bring up to $35 of economic benefits to the nation. The cost-benefit analysis of the value of discovering new species has never before been attempted in Australia. It comes as scientists launch a new mission to discover and document all Australian species that remain undiscovered and unnamed within a generation. An accompanying paper by Australian researchers has also shown that out of nearly 900 species of lizards and snakes, around a third could be a different species to what we thought,  and about 1 in 4 are likely to be unknown species, and many of the unknown species are threatened or likely to become threatened.

Media release

From: Australian Academy of Science

A new report by Deloitte Access Economics has found every $1 invested in discovering all remaining Australian species will bring up to $35 of economic benefits to the nation.

The cost-benefit analysis of the value of discovering new species has never before been attempted in Australia. It comes as scientists launch a new mission to discover and document all Australian species that remain undiscovered and unnamed within a generation.

The 25-year mission being launched today is led by the Australian Academy of Science’s Director of Taxonomy Australia, Adjunct Associate Professor Kevin Thiele.

He says many Australians would likely be quite surprised to know that after more than 300 years of Western scientific exploration of Australia’s rich biodiversity, only 30% of Australia’s estimated 750,000 species have been named and documented so far.

“Without this mission, it’s likely to take more than 400 years to discover all remaining Australian plants, animals, fungi and other organisms. A 16-fold increase in the annual rate of discovery is required over the next 25 years to meet this ambitious goal.

“Combining the skills of our current and future scientists with new technologies such as genome sequencing, artificial intelligence, and supercomputing makes this ambitious goal achievable by 2050.

“The successful completion of this mission will help build a path to a sustainable and prosperous future and place Australia among the first nations in the world to benefit from a fully documented biodiversity.

The mission is also expected to:

  • reduce green tape by providing more certainty to the resources sector;
  • help protect Australia’s agriculture and the environment from imported pests and diseases by reducing biosecurity risks;
  • stimulate new opportunities in agriculture, fisheries and aquaculture, pharmaceuticals and environmental management;
  • help ensure that conservation investments are targeted and effective; and
  • lead to new industries in emerging fields such as industrial food technologies and bioengineering.

The estimated cost of building capability needed to document the remaining estimated 600,000 Australian species yet discovered in a generation is $824 million over 25 years.

The mission’s initial focus will be to develop assets, including a national biobank and DNA sequence library, to ensure DNA sequences are available for all known Australian species. This would unlock enormous potential, from eDNA sequencing for environmental monitoring to bioprospecting, bioindustries and bioengineering.

Adjunct Associate Professor Thiele says the collection of more than 70 million scientific specimens in museums and herbaria in every Australian state and territory represents a $7 billion national science infrastructure and a solid foundation on which to build such a national biobank.

Insect expert Dr Erinn Fagan-Jeffries from The University of Adelaide is one of the Australian scientists involved in Taxonomy Australia’s new mission. Dr Fagan-Jeffries is researching the biodiversity and taxonomy of parasitoid wasps in Australia. She recently discovered and named four new species of wasp in collaboration with primary schools in regional South Australia.

Deloitte Access Economics partner and principle report author, Matt Judkins, says the modelling and analysis indicate that Taxonomy Australia’s mission is both ambitious and has strong potential to create significant economic and social benefits for the country.

“Benefits in the sectors of biosecurity, biodiscovery, agricultural R&D and biodiversity conservation attributable to accelerated taxonomic discovery range from $3.7 billion to $28.9 billion over a 25-year period to 2045, depending on the low, medium or high scenario cases defined for each benefit stream. This compares to the costs of investment in seven key categories estimated at $824 million over the same period.

“While a significant investment, and a lot of good will, will be required, Australia will have access to a much better understanding of its biodiversity and the risks it faces.”

Background information - What is taxonomy?

Taxonomy is the science of classifying living organisms and arranging them into groups to understand relationships between species. Taxonomists discover, discern, describe, name, classify, study, compare and identify the world’s living and extinct species and other taxa. Their core task is to document the living world.

The discipline provides the foundational ‘map’ of biodiversity: taxonomic names and classifications are the key framework around which global knowledge and understanding of biodiversity can be organised and accessed.

Expert Reaction

These comments have been collated by the Science Media Centre to provide a variety of expert perspectives on this issue. Feel free to use these quotes in your stories. Views expressed are the personal opinions of the experts named. They do not represent the views of the SMC or any other organisation unless specifically stated.

Brendan Wintle is a Professor in Conservation Ecology at the University of Melbourne, and Director of the National Threatened Species Recovery Research Hub.

The Mission to discover Australia’s remaining species is a critical national scientific undertaking if we are to tackle Australia’s extinction crisis.

In 200 years since the European invasion of Australia, we have officially acknowledged the extinction of 105 species, resulting mainly from land clearing for agriculture and invasive species. But the true number of extinctions over that period is likely to be much greater because many species are likely to have gone extinct before they were known to western science.

While the true number of Australian animals, plants and fungi species is unknown, it is estimated that western science has described just 30 per cent. So basic maths will tell you that we could well have lost at least 200 undescribed species since Europeans arrived in Australia.

Even in the last bushfires, it’s quite likely we lost some plant, insect or fungi species that were not yet known to western science.

Funding species discovery is a basic first step toward addressing Australia’s extinction crisis. If you don’t know what you’ve got, you cant protect it.

Unfortunately, funding for threatened species conservation in Australia is woeful, despite us having the highest rate of biodiversity loss in the developed world, and the second highest rate on the planet.

We need Commonwealth and State Governments to step up and properly fund discovery, protection and recovery our unique and precious Australian threatened species.

Last updated:  03 Jun 2021 11:13am
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Francesco Martoni is an early career Entomology Research Scientist working for Agriculture Victoria.

From an entomological point of view, discovering and describing new insect species is of paramount importance not only for a better understanding of Australian biodiversity but also to protect its agriculture and biosecurity.

Indeed, undescribed species may risk triggering expensive biosecurity responses if mistakenly identified as similar-looking pests. On the other hand, insect pest species may hide in plain sight, because too similar to harmless endemic groups and therefore hard to be targeted by pest management operations. This is due to the fact that describing and naming a species is the first step to further study its biology, in fact we often lack ecological and behavioural information on a species that has not been described.

Discovering a new species can provide the tools for its identification and enable to understand how to protect it, if a threatened endemic species, or how to fight it, if a newly emerged pest. Ultimately, described species bear a name that can be used by policymakers to determine the real biosecurity risk associated with a species, distinguishing it from closely related, harmless, native groups that need our protection.

Last updated:  02 Jun 2021 1:30pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Dr Leanda is an independent researcher based in Perth, Western Australia

Many thousands of Australian species are estimated to have gone extinct in the last few hundred years, without ever being formally recorded. Recent history has seen an increasing dependence on metrics such as GDP and population growth as measures of success in a global context, often with reckless abandonment for natural environments and species.

The economic benefit of natural environments and species is very difficult to measure because monetary value cannot be directly given and thus undervalued. Instead, value is measured ethically, morally or intrinsically such as with known benefits to disease control, mental health, climate and ecosystem stability. However, these indirect benefits are undervalued when the feasibility of economically driven projects are deliberated. Indeed, permanent costs to our natural environment and native species through land clearance are perceived as unfortunate, but necessary losses for economic productivity.

Ideally, providing a detailed account of how the discovery of new species may provide economic benefit may slow and eventually stop unsustainable developments that lead to species extinctions. However, it may be some time before traditional metrics of societal success become replaced with those that align with sustainable and equitable development. Until then, providing a tangible estimate to our economy will reflect at least a small proportion of the immense intrinsic worth of species discovery.

Last updated:  02 Jun 2021 10:17am
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Dr Erin Hahn is a Wildlife Geneticist and Postdoctoral Fellow at the Australian National Wildlife Collection at CSIRO

The AAS report provides a comprehensive and conservative estimate of the economic benefit of investing in cataloguing Australia’s incredibly diverse species. Australia’s biodiversity is like our life-support system and we rely on it for our survival despite not knowing fully how it works. 
 
Our knowledge gaps are largest with respect to invertebrates, fungi and microorganisms such as algae, bacteria and viruses. While our most charismatic and iconic Australian species are relatively well-characterised, their survival depends on many (yet-unknown) interactions with undescribed species. 
 
The AAS report captures the necessary multi-disciplinary workforce that will be required to achieve the ambitious task of discovering all Australian species. As a geneticist, I am particularly pleased to see a focus on supporting stream-lining of the generation of genetic data. Currently it can take a research team several years to conduct a fairly simple genetic study. That time-line will be dramatically reduced if the process were supported by coordinated genomics infrastructure. 
 
As a researcher working in the Australian National Wildlife Collection, I am pleased to see the focus on training a new generation of taxonomists. We are in a race against the clock of extinction and we need to deploy a network of highly-trained specialists to systematically discover what species we have before they are lost. Melville et al provides a framework for determining how to prioritise spending and effort in achieving this goal. Their framework relies on specialist taxonomy knowledge; therefore, we need to be promoting taxonomy as a viable career option to university students who will someday be leading conservation efforts. Geneticists such as myself cannot do the work of cataloguing species alone. We need the species-specific knowledge that only a taxonomist can provide to put our genetic data into context.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 4:54pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Professor Andrew Baird, ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies

The results of the PLOS One study are remarkable. Lizards and snakes are so familiar, present in every Australian backyard, it is hard to believe the taxonomy was so poorly understood. An increase in species richness of 25 per cent in the group is amazing. The results are similar to what we are finding on the Great Barrier Reef where we think there are up to three times more coral species than previous estimates.

The goal to name and find all Australian species in a decade is ambitious, but as the Deloitte Access Economics report suggests, the economic benefits will be huge. These are exciting times for Australian taxonomy.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 4:52pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Discovering and naming all of Australia’s species of animals, plants, fungi and other organisms is important for Australia’s prosperity and future wellbeing. Few people realise that only around a third of Australia’s species have been discovered so far, and that at current rate it will take more than four hundred years to discover and name the rest.

This means that many will go extinct before we know what they are, what they look like, what role they play in Australia’s environment, what opportunities they may offer and what threats they may face.

Species can only be conserved, managed and utilised if we know something about them. For the first time in history we have the technologies needed to discover and name all Australian species in a generation. All we need now is support and investment. We now know that naming and documenting all our species will bring direct economic benefits to Australia as well as ensuring that our species are protected for future generations. A mission to discover and document all our species will be a challenge on the same scale, and with similar costs and benefits, as other big science missions such as in space science and astronomy.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:44pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Kevin is the Australian Academy of Science’s Director of Taxonomy Australia, who commissioned the Deloitte report.

Dr Erinn Fagan-Jeffries is a Postdoctoral Research Associate in the University of Adelaide's School of Biological Sciences.

As an early career researcher in the field of taxonomy, it’s excellent to see the Deloitte Access Economics report state that the Taxonomy Australia mission to document all of the remaining species in Australia will bring significant economical benefits. Documenting the species that are in our environment gives us the knowledge to better manage our native and agricultural ecosystems, which is critical for the continued growth and health of society. It’s an exciting time to be part of this mission of scientific discovery, which with the right support and investment will be able to achieve its goals and bring benefits to all Australians.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:42pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Erinn is one of the Australian scientists involved in Taxonomy Australia’s new mission

Matt Judkins is Deloitte Access Economics partner and principle report author

Undertaking economic analysis to place a value on an activity is a common practice used to better prioritise investments and government support for initiatives. Prior to building a new port, stadium or museum, delivering improved health or education facilities or changing a government policy or regulation, economic analysis will often be undertaken to assess the number of jobs each activity will create and the economic uplift delivered to society.

Discovering and naming all of Australia’s species of animals, plants, fungi and other organisms is no different. It has the potential to deliver a significant economic dividend to Australia’s future prosperity. Deloitte Access Economics estimates for every dollar spent to undertake Taxonomy Australia’s mission over the next 25 years, the benefit will conservatively equate to between $4 and $35 to Australia. This is a significant dividend and reflects the value held within Australia’s unique biodiversity.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:41pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Matt is an author of the Deloitte report.

Dr Jane Melville is Senior Curator in Terrestrial Vertebrates at Museums Victoria and an Associate Professor at the School of Biological Sciences, Monash University. Jane is also the corresponding author of the PLOS One paper

Australia is one of Earth’s megadiverse countries – a group of 17 nations that are home to the majority of global species – but we really have only scratched the surface in discovering and naming all our species. The vast majority of species remain unknown. Naming and documenting all Australia’s species would have huge benefits across the board – for conservation of biodiversity, biosecurity, health, agriculture and more.

We now have a clearly defined path to achieving this goal and the benefits to us all have been definitively outlined in the Deloitte Access Economics report. The profound importance of this foundational information cannot be underestimated and with support and investment the mission to document and name all Australia’s species is now possible.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:39pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Jane is lead author on the PLOS paper.

Karli Jeffery is an Economist at Deloitte Access Economics

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:37pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Karli is an author of the Deloitte report

Professor Hugh Possingham is the Chief Scientist of Queensland

For too long conservation and biodiversity scientists have shunned the tools of economists - these papers show the benefits of using economic approaches to science and conservation.

These two publications show how return on investment and cost-benefit analysis thinking can help us make better decisions for prioritising actions and scientific research - bravo.

The economic thinking in these papers helps us to understand biodiversity and manage Australia’s rich natural heritage far more efficiently; plus, it shows the enormous benefits to Australia of increased investment in science and science-informed actions.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:35pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Dr Kit Prendergast is a Postdoctoral Researcher at University of Southern Queensland and Adjunct Research Fellow at Curtin University

Despite being a developed country, Australia lags behind many other places in the world regarding the discovery and description of our biodiversity. Australia, being isolated biogeographically for hundreds of thousands of years, has biota that have evolved in isolation, meaning we have very distinctive, unique species, most of which are found nowhere else in the world.

We already know we lead the world in the unglamorous position of suffering the greatest number of mammal extinctions in the last two centuries. We don't even know how many species we might stand to lose for most taxonomic groups - without knowing they exist, we can't effectively conserve them. Investing in biodiversity discovery and description is worthy, not just economically, but for Australia as a country in protecting our natural, irreplaceable, capital.

What is exciting here is the mission by Taxonomy Australia will importantly address some of the biggest taxonomic gaps - invertebrates. The estimates in the Melville et al. paper with snakes and lizards are just the tip of the iceberg!

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:31pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Kit is a member of Taxonomy Australia

Dr Pat Hutchings is a Senior Fellow at the Australian Museum in Sydney

Australia is facing unprecedented changes to the marine environment, yet we know little of the dominant animals, the segmented worms which live in the sediment. These animals play a critical role in the food chain being eaten by many other animals including commercially important species. They break down organic matter and aerate the sediments. Yet so much of this fauna is still undescribed, so how can we monitor these important communities for impacts of climate change if we do not know what species are present. How do we detect invasive species? Are they really invasive or just undescribed native species?  

How can we rectify this situation, we need to train the next generation of taxonomists and ensure that jobs are available, otherwise difficult to attract students. We also need to ensure that oceanographic cruises to explore Australian biodiversity off our coasts, includes funds to sort and identify this material when it comes back into Australian museums where most taxonomists reside. It is critical this is done asap as many of our marine invertebrate taxonomists are retired or close to retirement and critical that we mentor the next generation of taxonomist. Taxonomy is the basic building block of all biological science.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:27pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Professor David Lindenmayer AO is from the Fenner School of Environment and Society at the Australian National University

The work serves to illustrate what a remarkable continent Australia really is – the nation’s extraordinary levels of biodiversity – much of it remaining undiscovered. It shows what an exciting place it is to be a scientist, but also the critical custodial role that Australians have in protecting and conserving entire species that are found nowhere else.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:22pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Euan Ritchie is a Professor of Wildlife Ecology and Conservation at Deakin University

In essence, what the Deloitte Access Economics report and Melville and colleagues’ study demonstrate, is that describing and cataloguing Australia’s extraordinary and largely globally unique biodiversity does not constitute an economic cost, but rather a very savvy investment that delivers substantial financial and other benefits.

The same is true for environmental protection and restoration. By understanding how many species we have, where they live, and what’s needed for their survival, we would be in a much better position to protect Australia’s remarkable plants, animals, fungi, other species and ecosystems.

Investing in the protection, care and recovery of species and ecosystems presents a massive opportunity for governments, businesses and industries, to create jobs (e.g. pest animal control, wildlife and environmental monitoring, revegetation, Indigenous ranger programs, tourism) and help recover bushfire- and COVID19-ravaged businesses and communities. In doing so we could reap huge cultural, social, economic and environmental benefits. Let’s get to work!

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:19pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Ian Lowe is Emeritus professor of science, technology and society at Griffith University, Qld and former President of the Australian Conservation Foundation.^unescape

Twenty-five years ago, the first independent national report on the state of the environment estimated that Australia is home to about one million species, of which only 15 per cent had been described. It noted that we were losing our biodiversity 'at an alarming rate'. Our biodiversity is central to our cultural identity and critical for the integrity of natural systems on which we depend. This new report documents the economic importance of understanding our biodiversity. At the moment, we simply do not know the significance of what we are losing, so identifying and describing the species that we share this continent with is not just a scientific exercise. It is a critically important investment in our future.

Last updated:  01 Jun 2021 1:17pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None declared.

Tim Entwisle is an Honorary Professor in Biosciences at The University of Melbourne and former Director of Royal Botanic Gardens Victoria

I’m not at all surprised there is a huge economic benefit to discovering what lives in Australia. 

As a plant scientist and head of a botanic garden, I’m very aware that being able to identify and name a plant unlocks a vast array of benefits to that plant and to us. 

We need to discover and classify life on Earth so that species can survive in a changing world, so that we can control weeds and diseases, and so that we can develop new pharmaceuticals and agricultural crops. 

I love the ambition of documenting all Australian species within a generation. 

It’s time we took this Cinderella of sciences (taxonomy) seriously.

Last updated:  30 Apr 2024 4:34pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest "We employ taxonomists at Royal Botanic Gardens Victoria."

Multimedia

The race to identify Australia's unknown species

Attachments

Note: Not all attachments are visible to the general public. Research URLs will go live after the embargo ends.

Video Australian Academy of Science, Web page Download link
Journal/
conference:
Organisation/s: Australian Academy of Science
Funder: N/A
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.