Did WWI 'Razzle Dazzle' camouflage actually work for battleships?

Publicly released:
International
WW1 troopship 'Osterley' in camouflage
WW1 troopship 'Osterley' in camouflage

The 'Razzle Dazzle' ship camouflage strategy likely only worked for fast, distant battleships during World War I, according to international researchers.  Some WWI ships were painted with high contrast patterns aimed at making them harder for submarines to target. To investigate how well the camouflage worked, the researchers put together a computer simulation of the RMS Mauretania with different camouflage patterns, and tested how well 16 participants could tell where the ship was moving. The researchers say some patterns they tested made ships appear to be moving in a different direction, but this trickery was likely only effective for ships that were far away and travelling quickly.

Media release

From: The Royal Society

  • Razzle dazzle – The effects of ‘dazzle’ camouflage painted on WWI ships to protect them from submarine attacks may have been less than dazzling. Participants viewed a computer simulation with ships painted in six camouflage patterns. While some patterns ‘twisted’ the perceived direction travel and made the ships appear to move along the horizon rather than towards or away from participants, the authors suggest that only fast, distant ships would have benefited. Royal Society Open Science.

Dazzle camouflage: Benefits and problems revealed
Royal Society Open Science
WWI ships were painted with high contrast ‘dazzle’ patterns to make it harder for submarines to attack them, but did it work? We measured how dazzle camouflage influenced perception of heading. Patterns with a gradient, where elements get smaller towards the ship's bow, ‘twisted’ the perceived direction of travel. But a second effect made it look like ships were moving across the horizon, rather than towards or away from participants, regardless of dazzle camouflage, though less so for experienced seafarers. These effects combined to either enhance or diminish protection from torpedoes. Dazzle provided potential protection only for fast distant ships.

Attachments

Note: Not all attachments are visible to the general public. Research URLs will go live after the embargo ends.

Research The Royal Society, Web page The URL will go live after the embargo ends
Journal/
conference:
Royal Society Open Science
Research:Paper
Organisation/s: Abertay University, UK
Funder: No funding has been received for this article.
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.