EXPERT REACTION: Whaling impacts live on, even as humpbacks recover

Publicly released:
New Zealand; International
PHOTO: Chinh Le Duc on Unsplash
PHOTO: Chinh Le Duc on Unsplash

Whaling may have had lasting genetic impacts on Southern Ocean humpback whales, possibly making them more vulnerable, according to an international study. Researchers compared the DNA in skin samples from 16 living humpbacks to the DNA in the bones of 9 whales from the early days of whaling, before the humpbacks were nearly wiped out. They found that although their numbers are recovering, modern humpbacks have lower genetic diversity and more slightly harmful mutations than historical whales, although very harmful mutations had not increased. The researchers explained that genetic diversity is the raw material for evolution, so having less of it means that humpback whales may be less able to adapt to future changes in their Southern Ocean home.

Expert Reaction

These comments have been collated by the Science Media Centre to provide a variety of expert perspectives on this issue. Feel free to use these quotes in your stories. Views expressed are the personal opinions of the experts named. They do not represent the views of the SMC or any other organisation unless specifically stated.

Associate Professor Emma Carroll, School of Biological Sciences, University of Auckland

"Whaling was arguably the first large scale human industry that caused a biodiversity crisis – in the Southern Ocean alone, it killed over 2 million whales, forever changing our ecosystems. For humpback whales, the whaling industry was relatively brief compared with other species like right and bowhead whales. Such a brief population bottleneck (sudden shrinking of the population), from which many humpback whale populations have successfully bounced back - like East Australia, number over 30,000 whales - wouldn’t be expected to have a big impact on the genomes of these whales. This is because genomic diversity is lost on a timescale of generations, and whales, like us, live a long time.

"This new research challenges this paradigm, by a showing reduction in genomic diversity, and the accumulation of potentially harmful versions of genes, in humpback whales alive today compared to those in the whaling era. However, the samples used in this study came from one region of the Southern Ocean; including samples from more populations may reveal more diversity in today’s humpback whales. Nonetheless, it is a compelling example of how genomes from a relatively small number of animals can provide insight into the history of their populations and the impact of human exploitation."

Last updated:  16 Dec 2025 11:51am
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest Conflicts of interest statement: "None to declare."
Journal/
conference:
Science Advances
Research:Paper
Organisation/s: University of Groningen, Netherlands
Funder: This project was in part funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme, SeaChanges ITN Marie Skłodowska-­Curie grant agreement no. 813383 to P.J.P. and F.F., the Brazilian National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq) grants INTERBIOTA (407889/2013-2) and Baleias (557064/2009-0) to E.R.S., a Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (DGECR-2019-00426) to C.F.S., and the MITACS Globalink research award to F.F.
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.