Moving turtle nests to save the eggs can have hidden consequences

Publicly released:
Australia; NSW; QLD
Adobe Stock
Adobe Stock

Sea turtle hatchlings face a difficult start to life, with a mad dash across open beach under constant attack from predators. Only about 1 in a thousand will ever make it to adulthood. Climate change is also having an impact, and temperature fluctuations not only destroy whole nests, they can also result in clutches being born over 90% female (incubation temperature determines sex). Conservationists often move doomed nests, but a new UNSW study suggests that might have unintended consequences. Hatchlings are smaller and are less good at righting themselves if they flip over, big problems when the odds are already so heavily stacked against them.

News release

From: The University of New South Wales

Moving turtle nests to save the eggs can have hidden consequences

Moving threatened sea turtle nests to cooler, safer parts of the beach can save entire clutches from rising tides and extreme heat, but new research suggests it may have hidden consequences for the hatchlings that emerge.

UNSW researchers studied 48 green turtle clutches over two nesting seasons on Heron Island on the southern Great Barrier Reef, comparing natural nests with those relocated under shade cloth and relocated nests left unshaded.

Incubation temperature is known to determine hatchling sex, and the unshaded relocated nests were hotter and produced overwhelmingly female hatchlings, with just 8% of those sampled in one season estimated to be male.

Shading reduced temperatures and produced a more balanced sampled sex ratio.

But even when shaded relocated nests reached similar temperatures to natural nests, they had lower hatching success and produced hatchlings that were smaller and less able to right themselves when flipped over.

“The difference shows up even when the shaded and natural nests are the same temperature,” says UNSW sea turtle ecologist Davey Dor, lead author of the study published in Marine Biology.

Only one in a thousand turtle hatchlings will survive until breeding age of 30 years old, and small differences in physical performance can be the difference between life and death.

Hatchlings on Heron Island face a 50-metre scramble across the beach while avoiding birds and ghost crabs before reaching the water.

Mr Dor says they don’t fully understand why relocation impacts hatchlings like this, but suggests that moisture, sand conditions, gas exchange, microbes and nest depth could all play a role.

Researchers now want to understand which factors are affecting hatchling development.

“We can't pin it to a single factor,” Mr Dor says.

Mr Dor says the findings don't mean conservationists should stop relocating nests that would otherwise be lost.

“Nest relocation as a conservation strategy has been used all over the world for a long time now.”

“We need to understand these factors so we can give the turtles we're trying to save the best possible chance of survival.”

Journal/
conference:
Marine Biology
Research:Paper
Organisation/s: The University of New South Wales, The University of Queensland
Funder: Open Access funding enabled and organized by CAUL and its Member Institutions. This project was supported by the UNSW Faculty of Science Social Good Seed Fund 2021 as well as The Holsworth Wildlife Research Endowment & The Ecological Society of Australia.
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.