Autism may not be less common in girls than boys

Publicly released:
International
CC-0. Story by Dr Joe Milton, Australian Science Media Centre
CC-0. Story by Dr Joe Milton, Australian Science Media Centre

It's long been believed that autism disproportionately affects boys, with roughly four times as many diagnoses. However, new Swedish research suggests rates are actually similar in girls, but the condition tends to be diagnosed later than in boys, not until adolescence. The team looked at autism diagnoses in 2.7 million Swedes, tracked from birth to at least 37 years old. They found autism was diagnosed in 78,522 (2.8%) people at an average age of 14.3 years. Males were more likely to be diagnosed in childhood, they say, but females caught up during adolescence, giving a male to female ratio approaching 1:1 by 20 years of age. The findings suggest the male to female ratio for autism has decreased over time and with increasing age of diagnosis. The male to female ratio may be substantially lower than we thought, the authors say, to the extent that it may almost disappear by adulthood. Although the study has a few limitations, the authors say the results highlight the need to investigtate why girls are less likely than boys to get an autism diagnosis early.

News release

From: BMJ Group

Rates of autism in girls and boys may be more equal than previously thought

Study raises questions around why female individuals are diagnosed later than males

Autism has long been viewed as a condition that predominantly affects male individuals, but a study from Sweden published by The BMJ shows that autism may actually occur at comparable rates among male and female individuals.

The results show a clear female catch-up effect during adolescence, which the researchers say highlights the need to investigate why female individuals receive diagnoses later than male individuals.

The prevalence of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has increased over the past three decades, with a high male-to-female diagnosis ratio of around 4:1.

The increase in prevalence is thought to be linked to factors including wider diagnostic criteria and societal changes (eg, parental age), whilst the high male to female ratio has been attributed to better social and communication skills among girls, making autism more difficult to spot. However so far no large study has examined these trends over the life course.

To address this, researchers used national registers to analyse diagnosis rates of autism for 2.7 million individuals born in Sweden between 1985 and 2022 who were tracked from birth to a maximum of 37 years of age.

During this follow-up period of more than 35 years, autism was diagnosed in 78,522 (2.8%) of individuals at an average age of 14.3 years.

Diagnosis rates increased with each five year age interval throughout childhood, peaking at 645.5 per 100,000 person years for male individuals at age 10-14 years and 602.6 for female individuals at age 15-19 years.

However, while male individuals were more likely to have a diagnosis of autism in childhood, female individuals caught up during adolescence, giving a male to female ratio approaching 1:1 by age 20 years.

This is an observational study and the authors acknowledge that they did not consider other conditions associated with autism, such as ADHD and intellectual disability. Nor were they able to control for shared genetic and environmental conditions like parental mental health.

However, they say the study size and duration enabled them to link data for a whole population and disentangle the effects of three different time scales: age, calendar period and birth cohort.

As such, they write: “These findings indicate that the male to female ratio for autism has decreased over time and with increasing age at diagnosis. This male to female ratio may therefore be substantially lower than previously thought, to the extent that, in Sweden, it may no longer be distinguishable by adulthood.”

“These observations highlight the need to investigate why female individuals receive diagnoses later than male individuals,” they conclude.

These findings align with recent research and seem to support the argument that current practices may be failing to recognise autism in many women until later in life, if at all, says Anne Cary, patient and patient advocate, in a linked editorial.

She notes that studies like this are essential to changing the assumption that autism is more prevalent in male individuals than in female individuals, but points out that as autistic female individuals await proper diagnosis, “they are likely to be (mis)diagnosed with psychiatric conditions, especially mood and personality disorders, and they are forced to self-advocate to be seen and treated appropriately: as autistic patients, just as autistic as their male counterparts.”

Attachments

Note: Not all attachments are visible to the general public. Research URLs will go live after the embargo ends.

Research BMJ Group, Web page The URL will go live after the embargo ends
Editorial / Opinion BMJ Group, Web page The URL will go live after the embargo ends
Journal/
conference:
The BMJ
Research:Paper
Organisation/s: Karolinska Institutet, Sweden
Funder: This work was supported by the Simons Foundation (PTE Grant 7340697, the Karolinska Institutet’s Research Foundation (grants Dnr 2018-01499 and 2020-02156 (to SS) and grant 2022-02021 (to WY)) and by the Horizon 2020 award 733280 RECAP Research on Children and Adults Born Preterm (grant to SS).
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.