EXPERT REACTION: 2024 was the first year above 1.5C warming, so what does that mean for the Paris Agreement target?

Publicly released:
International; NSW; VIC
Photo by Carl Wang on Unsplash
Photo by Carl Wang on Unsplash

1.5°C of global warming above pre-industrial thresholds is likely already underway, according to two international modelling studies. Both papers investigated how 2024 - the first year where average temperatures exceeded 1.5°C of warming - impacts the Paris Agreement stretch target of keeping warming below that level. The researchers say the Agreement looks at averages over a 20-30 year period to allow for exceptionally hot years, so they looked at historical climate data to see whether exceptionally hot years that passed other warming thresholds signified the passing of that threshold long-term. In the first paper, the researchers say it's likely we are currently living somewhere in the middle of the first 20 years of 1.5°C warming. In the second paper, researchers looked at month-to-month data considering June 2024 was the twelfth consecutive month of 1.5°C warming. They say models show 12 consecutive months above a climate threshold indicate that the threshold has already been reached.

Media release

From: Springer Nature

Climate change: Assessing the impact of 2024 temperatures on Paris Agreement targets

The potential likelihood of exceeding the Paris Agreement goals of limiting warming to 1.5 °C above pre-industrial temperatures is explored in two papers published in Nature Climate Change. Both papers suggest that exceeding 1.5 °C of warming in 2024 may indicate we have entered a multi-decadal period of 1.5°C average global warming, and stringent climate mitigation efforts are needed to keep the Paris Agreement goals within reach.

In 2015, the Paris Agreement set the goal of limiting human-induced global warming to 1.5 °C above a pre-industrial baseline. The temperature targets of the Paris Agreement are understood to refer to averages over 20–30-year periods in order to remove the impact of natural short-term variations of the climate system such as El Niño. Current modelling suggests that the 20-year warming threshold will be breached in the late 2020s or early 2030s. Recently, it was announced that 2024 was the first year to breach 1.5 °C relative to pre-industrial levels, but how this effects the long-term goals for meeting the Paris Agreement is unclear.

To explore the relationship between single warm years and longer-term warming trends, Emanuele Bevacqua and colleagues combined climate observations and modelling from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6), focusing on models that represented warming trends from 1981 to 2014. Looking at historical warming trends, the authors suggest that the first single year where temperatures breach different temperature thresholds from 0.6 °C to 1 °C above pre-industrial temperatures also fall in the first 20-year period in which a year’s average temperatures reached those respective thresholds. This pattern suggests that Earth may have entered the 20-year warming period as temperatures have breached 1.5 °C in 2024.

When the authors modelled different climate scenarios it was likely (greater than or equal to 66% probability) to virtually certain (greater than or equal to 99% probability) that 2024 falls within the first 20-year period where the 1.5 °C target is reached, depending on the climate scenario. Under the Shared Socioeconomic Pathway SSP2–4.5 scenario, which most closely resembles current climate policies, all models indicated that the first year above 1.5 °C would fall into the 20-year warming period. The authors caution that the entry time in the 20-year period at 1.5 °C warming should not be mistaken as the timing of the warming level itself, as the latter is likely to occur at the midpoint of the 20-year period.

In a second paper using modelling data from CMIP6, Alex Cannon notes that June 2024 was the 12th month in a row with temperatures above 1.5 °C and explores how this may affect the Paris Agreement targets. Under existing models, Cannon notes that projections of 12  months of consistent temperatures above 1.5 °C tend to occur when long-term (i.e. over a 20-year average) warming has already been reached. It is calculated that under SSP2–4.5, it is 76% likely this has happened, and under SSP1–2.6, there is a 56% chance this has occurred. Cannon notes that based on the modelling, if 18 consecutive months of temperatures at or above 1.5 °C occurs then breaching the Paris Agreement is virtually certain under SSP2–4.5.

The papers use different methodologies and time periods, which accounts for some of the differences in their results. However, the authors of both articles point out that rapid and strong mitigation efforts can still substantially reduce the likelihood of crossing the Paris Agreement’s temperature targets over the next years to decades.

Expert Reaction

These comments have been collated by the Science Media Centre to provide a variety of expert perspectives on this issue. Feel free to use these quotes in your stories. Views expressed are the personal opinions of the experts named. They do not represent the views of the SMC or any other organisation unless specifically stated.

Dr Tom Mortlock is Head of Climate Analytics Asia-Pacific at Aon, and Adjunct Fellow in the Climate Change Research Centre at UNSW

2024 was the warmest year on record globally, with average temperatures exceeding 1.5 degrees. While often used interchangeably, this is not the same thing as breaching the Paris Agreement threshold of 1.5 degrees. 

The problem with the Paris agreement is that there was no formal definition of what 1.5 meant, but it is widely assumed that it refers to the IPCC’s definition – which defines this in terms of 20-year blocks of time relative to the average for 1850-1900. While that definition works for climate model projections, when it comes to yearly observations it means we won’t know if we’ve officially crossed the Paris line until a decade after it happens.

This new research attempts to overcome this problem using climate model simulations, and suggests that 2024 may indeed indicate that we have breached the Paris 1.5 mark. Whether we have or not, the fact remains that we only have about six years left in the global carbon budget emitting at current rates to give ourselves a 50/50 chance of still making the Paris target. If this new research is correct, 2024 may be the first sign that we have already overshot this target.

Last updated:  07 Feb 2025 11:44am
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None

Dr Andrew King is an Associate Professor in Climate Science at the University of Melbourne and the ARC Centre of Excellence for 21st Century Weather

Recently we've seen individual days, months and even the year of 2024 exceed the 1.5°C global warming mark relative to pre-industrial levels. While this is very concerning, climate scientists have cautioned that this doesn't mean we've failed to meet the Paris Agreement goals. This is because the warming levels in the Paris Agreement refer to longer climate periods rather than short excursions over the 1.5°C level.

What these new studies highlight is how these single months and years over the 1.5°C mark are likely to be features of a longer period the world has entered in which the climate averages more than 1.5°C of global warming. In fact, without rapid decarbonisation it is hard to avoid the climate entering a longer phase of global warming above the 1.5°C level.

While this won't surprise too many climate scientists, these studies are a timely reminder of how far we really are from tackling climate change properly. Global greenhouse gas emissions remain at or near record levels and global warming has even accelerated in recent years. A major shift is needed to decarbonise our society and economy otherwise we will keep warming the planet and causing more and more damage.

Last updated:  07 Feb 2025 11:43am
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None

Milton Speer is a Visiting Fellow in the School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences at the University of Technology Sydney

Just published research that points to the most recent consecutive twelve months global average temperature at 1.5 °C [above pre-industrial levels] signals an earlier than expected breach of the Paris Agreement threshold while different research concludes that the most recent 12 months above 1.5 °C signals that Earth is most probably within the 20-year period that will reach the Paris Agreement limit.

Evidence supports the aforementioned research more strongly because using long-term temperature and rainfall averages of periods like 30 years, currently used to define climate by the World Meteorological Organization, or indeed 20 years, are now unsuitable for defining climate (see:- https://theconversation.com/unprecedented-climate-extremes-are-everywhere-our-baselines-for-whats-normal-will-need-to-change-24429)

In recent decades, there has been a glaring disconnect between the current definition of climate periods as the means [averages] of 30 consecutive years and the more appropriate means [averages] of decadal or shorter periods. It is generally known now that global warming (GW) and climate impacts have accelerated since the 1990s. As a result, global climate regimes are now increasingly being driven by GW, modulated by the phases of climate drivers relevant to the location of interest.

There is a need for a combined statistical-climate model approach to climate prediction. Climate models are needed to predict the future phases of the climate drivers based on updated climate drivers that can be attained over periods more appropriately comprising a few years.

Last updated:  07 Feb 2025 12:09pm
Contact information
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.
Declared conflicts of interest None

Attachments

Note: Not all attachments are visible to the general public. Research URLs will go live after the embargo ends.

Research Springer Nature, Web page Paper 1. The URL will go live after the embargo ends
Research Springer Nature, Web page Paper 2. The URL will go live after the embargo ends
Journal/
conference:
Nature Climate Change
Research: Link to Paper 1 | Paper 2
Organisation/s: Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research–UFZ, Leipzig, Germany (Paper 1), Environment and Climate Change Canada (Paper 2)
Funder: Paper 1: E.B. received funding from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) via the Emmy Noether Programme (grant ID 524780515). C.-F.S. acknowledges support from European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programmes under grant agreement no. 101003687 (PROVIDE). J.Z. acknowledges the Helmholtz Initiative and Networking Fund (Young Investigator Group COMPOUNDX, grant agreement VH-NG-1537). This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement no. 101003469. The authors acknowledge the World Climate Research Programme, which, through its Working Group on Coupled Modelling, coordinated and promoted CMIP6, and the authors thank the climate modelling groups for producing and making available their model output, the Earth System Grid Federation for archiving the data and providing access, and the multiple funding agencies who support CMIP and the Earth System Grid Federation. Analyses were carried out on the High-Performance Computing Cluster EVE, a joint effort of both the Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research–UFZ and the German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv) Halle-Jena-Leipzig. Paper 2: None reported
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.