Doctors call on health professionals to state 'politically inconvenient' evidence

Publicly released:
New Zealand
Tom Ackroyd, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons
Tom Ackroyd, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

In a NZ Medical Journal editorial, doctors say the safety of our health system is under threat. They say that for a long time the government has made reducing health inequities a priority, and there is a lot of research about interventions that can help, making them evidence-based rather than "ideological". They outline examples of interventions that were recently stopped, like smokefree legislation and lowering the bowel cancer screening age for Māori and Pacific people, arguing this is because science doesn't match current government ideology. The authors conclude that professionals should be able to speak honestly about risks to health, and have an obligation to do so.

News release

From: New Zealand Medical Journal (NZMJ)

The Government has made several recent moves that serve to silence, sideline or publicly
discredit health professionals and scientific experts. Our safe health system and democracy
depend on health professionals being able to speak out transparently and without fear. We share
our concerns that the government is risking public safety by undermining these important
safeguards when faced with the uncomfortable fact that a number of their health policy
decisions are contradicted by science.

Journal/
conference:
New Zealand Medical Journal
Organisation/s: University of Auckland
Funder: N/A. Competing interests: RJ has received: travel reimbursement (December 2023) from One Health Aotearoa; travel reimbursement (December 2023) from the State of Australasian Cities Conference; travel reimbursement (April 2024) from the World Health Summit; travel reimbursement (September 2024) from the New Zealand College of Public Health Medicine; travel and honorarium (June 2025) from the Climate and Health Conference; and honorarium (September 2025) for a University of Melbourne lecture. RJ is co-director of Climate Health Aotearoa (unpaid role).
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.