Clue Republicans in on climate change with the carrot, not stick

Publicly released:
International
CC:0
CC:0

US researchers found that a tailored message, specifically for Republicans, could be the best way to sway the opinions of right-wingers to the importance of curbing climate change. The team say that by 2020, 73 per cent of Americans believed that global warming was happening and 62 percent understood it was caused by human activities, however this was largely driven by the Left. To increase these numbers, the researchers used a series of persuasion theories in videos presented by a person that would resonate with Republicans. Following the campaign, the team say the belief that global warming is happening, is caused by humans, is personally important, and will cause harm to the future of humanity went up by several percentage points. As only 22 per cent of Republicans agreed that global warming was a 'high' or 'very high' priority, the researchers say getting the message through should be top priority.

Media release

From: Springer Nature

Tailored online messaging shifts Republican voters' understanding of climate change

Tailoring online messages to appeal to the ideals of Republican voters in the United States can increase their understanding of climate change and its risks and importance, according to a paper published in Nature Climate Change. Increasing public understanding among conservative voters is necessary to ensure bipartisan support for climate policies and action in the US.

By 2020, 73% of Americans believed that global warming was happening and 62% understood that it was caused by human activities. However, this shift in public opinion is largely driven by Democrats. Previous research has shown that, when asked how high a priority global warming should be for the President and Congress, 83% of Democrats said it should be a ‘high’ or ‘very high’ priority, whereas only 22% of Republicans agreed. Climate change communication is more likely to persuade people when the message and messenger resonate with the audience’s values and identities. Therefore, targeted communication strategies to increase Republican engagement around climate change are needed.

Matthew Goldberg and colleagues conducted a one-month advertising campaign field experiment targeting tailored, climate change-themed online messages to conservative voters in two competitive congressional districts (Missouri-02 and Georgia-07). The campaign presented a series of videos called New Climate Voices. This series, which used social identity theory, elite cues and theories of persuasion, was presented by spokespersons who were likely to resonate with conservatives. A comparison of results from 1,600 surveys administered before and after the campaign revealed that the videos increased understanding among Republicans in these two districts that global warming is happening and that it is being ‘caused mostly by human activities’ by several percentage points. Beliefs that climate change is ‘somewhat’, ‘very’ or ‘extremely’ personally important, and that it will cause a ‘moderate’ to ‘great deal’ of harm to future generations, also increased.

In an associated News & Views article, Phillip Ehret remarks that “these findings demonstrate that messages can be designed and used to change Republicans’ beliefs, even on highly polarized and politically charged issues — as long as the right strategy is used in the right way”.

Journal/
conference:
Nature Climate Change
Research:Paper
Organisation/s: Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA
Funder: Fenton Communications (A.L.), the Heising-Simons Foundation (A.L.), and the MacArthur Foundation (A.L.)
Media Contact/s
Contact details are only visible to registered journalists.