Hot or cold, climate helped shape your nose

Arslan A. Zaidi and colleagues.
Embargoed until: Publicly released:
PLOS Genetics

Our noses are one of our most distinctive facial features, and they do the important job of conditioning the air we breathe so it's warm and moist when it reaches our lungs. The vast variety of snoz shapes across the world aren't just the result of chance, according to US scientists, but are due, at least in part, to local climatic conditions. Prior research had shown people in hot, humid places tended to have wider nostrils than those in cold and dry environments. But a new study has found the differences in noses between people with West Africa, South African, East Asian or Northern European ancestry are greater than explained by chance alone.

  • Location of Interest:
  • International
Pennsylvania State University, USA
  • Health / Medical
  • Environment / Climate / Energy
Last updated: Tue 18 Jul 2017 Funder: This work was supported in part by the United States National Institute of Justice, the United States Department of Defense, the University of Illinois Interdisciplinary Innovation Initiative Research Grant, the Flemish Institute for the Promotion of Innovation by Science and Technology in Flanders (IWT Vlaanderen), the Research Program of the Fund for Scientific Research - Flanders (Belgium), and the Center for Human Evolution and Development at Penn State.

Media Release

From: PLOS

Climate had a hand in shaping the human nose

Temperature and humidity of ancestral environment are linked to differences in nostril width across human populations

The size and shape of the nose in different human populations is not simply the result of chance, but evolved, at least in part, in response to local climate conditions, report Arslan Zaidi and Mark Shriver of Pennsylvania State University, in a study published March 16th, 2017, in PLOS Genetics.

The nose is one of humanity’s most distinctive facial features, which also has the important job of conditioning the air that we breathe, to ensure that it is warm and moist when it reaches the lungs, which helps to prevent infections. Previous studies suggest that people whose ancestors lived in hot, humid places tend to have wider nostrils than people whose ancestors came from cold and dry environments, but whether these differences arose in response to local climates or just due to chance was unknown. In the current study, researchers examined the size and shape of noses on people with West African, South Asian, East Asian, or Northern European ancestry and found that differences in nose shape across these populations are greater than can be explained by chance alone. Additionally, wider nostrils are correlated with ancestors who evolved in warmer temperatures and with greater absolute humidity, suggesting that climate was one factor driving nasal evolution. The nose has had a complex evolutionary history, however, and researchers suspect that additional factors, such as cultural preferences when picking a mate, have also played a role in shaping the nose.

Investigations into nose shape evolution and climate adaptation may have medical as well as anthropological implications. Studies of human adaptation are essential to our understanding of disease and yield insights into why certain conditions, such as sickle cell anemia, lactose intolerance or skin cancer, are more common in certain populations. The researchers suggest that it may be worth investigating whether the shape of the nose and the size of the nasal cavity impact one’s risk of contracting a respiratory disease when living in a climate that is different from one’s ancestors.

Arslan A. Zaidi adds: "Even though there are substantial differences in nose shape among human populations, much of this variation can be explained by random genetic drift alone. This finding is in line with the consensus that most human variation is shared among populations and primarily due to genetic drift. Traits like skin pigmentation and nostril width are exceptions rather than the rule. Having said that, these traits are important to study because they are likely tied to our health, especially as we become more of a global community and migrate to new climes."

Document type Source Extra info Type / Size Last modified
 Research PLOS The URL will go live after the embargo ends. Web page 14 Mar 2017 9:19am

Multimedia

  • Climate and nose shape

    It is thought that differences in nose shape evolved across human populations as a result of local adaptation to climate, and not merely due to genetic drift. By comparing phenotypic and genetic differentiation across populations, we show that while most aspects of nose shape seem to be evolving neutrally, the width of the nares shows signals of climate adaptation. The figure is an artistic representation of our findings. The diverging tree represents the evolutionary process underlying population-differentiation in nose shape, a quantitative trait. Blue boxes represent alleles for narrower nares while red boxes represent alleles for wider nares. Colors in between represent intermediate phenotypes.

    File Size: 152.7 KB

    Attribution: Arslan A. Zaidi and colleagues.

    Permission Category: © - Only use with this story

    Last Modified: 14 Mar 2017 9:18am

    Note: High resolution files are only available for download by registered journalists.